IEER ENERGY & SECURITY No. 3

Science for the Critical Masses:
How Plutonium Changes with Time

"Science for the Critical Masses" will be a regular feature in Energy & Security. It will provide readers with some technical background to the policy questions discussed in each issue, as well as the chance to test your understanding of these technical points. Notice that there are several missing values in Table 2. Fill in them in based on the information provided in the accompanying article. The answers will appear in the next issue.


A typical plutonium sample is not pure plutonium-239, but consists of a mixture of isotopes. There are 15 isotopes of plutonium, with mass numbers ranging from 232 to 246. They are all radioactive-that is, their nuclei decay and in the process new elements are formed. All of the decay products of plutonium isotopes are also radioactive. Hence, each plutonium isotope forms a decay chain. A simplified decay chain of plutonium-239 is shown in Table 3 .

The isotopes commonly found in plutonium made in nuclear reactors range from plutonium-238 to plutonium-242. The amount of isotopes other than plutonium-239 produced in military or commercial reactors depends on the nature of the fuel used, the design of the reactor and to length of irradiation time.

Table 1 shows the two most common variants of plutonium isotope mixtures. The first is weapons-grade plutonium (often abbreviated WPu), which contains 93 percent or more plutonium-239. The other is a typical composition of reactor-grade plutonium (often abbreviated RPu), as produced in nuclear power reactors of the light water design. Note that reactor-grade plutonium from light water reactors usually contains more than 20 percent plutonium-240 and more than 10 percent plutonium-241. Plutonium produced in other reactors, such as graphite-moderated reactors (some of which are in operation in Britain, Russia, and elsewhere) or heavy water reactors used in Canada and elsewhere, has a composition in between that shown for weapons grade and reactor grade plutonium in the table. Table 1 also gives the half-life and specific activity of the most common plutonium isotopes. The half-life refers to the amount of time it takes for one-half of the atoms in a given sample to disintegrate. The specific activity (which is inversely related to half-life), indicates the radioactivity of a certain weight of material.

TABLE 1
Plutonium Isotope Half-life years Specific activity,curries per gram Amount in weapons grade plutonium, percent Amount in reactor grade plutonium,
percent1
plutonium-238 87.74 17.3 --- 1.3
plutonium-239 24,110 0.063 93.0 56.6
plutonium-240 6,537 0.23 6.5 23.2
plutonium-241 14.4 104 0.5 13.9
plutonium-242 379,00 .004 --- 4.9

1 Typical for pressurized water reactors, the most common type of reactor in operation.

Both weapons grade and reactor grade plutonium contain some plutonium-241. Plutonium-241 decays into americium-241 by emitting a beta particle. Since americium-241 has a far longer half-life (432 years) than plutonium-241 (14.4 years), it builds up as plutonium-241 decays. The gamma radiation from americium-241 decay, which is far stronger than that from plutonium-239, also builds up with the age of the plutonium sample. Therefore, the more plutonium-241 there is and the older the sample, the greater the gamma radiation from the build-up of americium-241.

Since reactor-grade plutonium contains substantial amounts of plutonium-241, the older the sample, the greater the radiation dose to workers handling it. When countries use plutonium separated from light water reactor spent fuel to make mixed oxide fuel (MOX fuel), older plutonium samples result in greater radiation doses to MOX plant workers. Older MOX plants are designed to handle reactor grade plutonium that is less than about two years old after reprocessing (which removes americium isotopes present in the spent fuel). Newer MOX plants can handle reactor-grade plutonium that is about three years old. Thus, countries like Japan and Russia that are not using reactor grade plutonium but have been separating it and stockpiling it for many years have wasted a great deal of money because the older plutonium will probably have to be reprocessed again to remove the americium-241. Therefore, it would be financially prudent, even for MOX proponents, to stop reprocessing until reasonably close to the time when the plutonium is actually fabricated into fuel.

Table 2 shows how americium-241 would build up in a 200 gram sample of reactor grade plutonium containing 1 gram of plutonium-241 at the time of reprocessing. It contains a blank column for the reader to fill in as an exercise to sharpen your technical skills. Note that the half-life of plutonium-241 is 14.4 years and that for every half-life, one-half of the plutonium-241 decays into americium-241. We are neglecting the decay of americium-241 for simplicity and since 28.8 years is a short time compared to its half life of 432 years.

TABLE 2
Isotope Initial composition after 2 years after 5 years after 14.4 years after 28.8 years
plutonium-241 1 0.91 ? 0.5 ?
americium-241 0 0.09 ? 0.5 ?

TABLE 3
Main Branches of the
Plutonium -239
Decay Series
Plutonium-239
(half-life: 24,110)
alpha decay
Uranium-235
(half-life: 704,000,000)
alpha decay
Thorium-231
(half-life: 25.2 hours)
beta decay
Protactinium-231
(half-life: 32,700 years)
alpha decay
Actinium
(half-life:21.8 years)
beta decay
Thorium-227
(half-life: 18.72 days)
alpha decay
Radium-233
(half-life:11.43 days)
alpha decay
Radon-219
(half-life: 3.96 seconds)
alpha decay
Polonium-215
(half-life: 1.78 milliseconds)
alpha decay
Lead-211
(half-life: 36.1 minutes)
beta decay
Bismuth-211
(half-life: 2.15 minutes)
alpha decay
Thallium-207
(half-life: 4.77 minutes)
beta decay
Lead-207
(half-life: stable)
Half-life values from
CRC Hanbook of Chemistry
and Physics



Return to E&S No.3 Main Page
Return to E&S Homepage
Return to IEER Homepage

Institute for Energy and Environmental Research

Comments to Outreach Coordinator: ieer@ieer.org
Takoma Park, Maryland, USA

December, 1997